Gerrard St. Bakery

This place smelled so go that I had to go in a get a butter tart (not photographed). The pecan butter tart was delicious if a little expensive, would definitely recommend. Went back for a little birthday treat and they sadly didn’t have any butter tarts with pecans in them so I tried the apple tart. It was just okay, pastry was fine and the filling wasn’t anything special. Would definitely go back for butter tarts but not the apple one.

I absolutely love Gerrard St. Bakery! I can’t tell you how many times I’ve said “this is the best dessert I’ve ever had”. I recently tried the butterscotch brownie and it was out of this world!

Shoutout to Scarlett for her great customer service that always comes with a smile!

Great customer service. Bought 2 buttermilk pecan tarts and a lemon tart. The buttermilk pecan tart was way too sweet but, the lemon tart was amazing. Will need to try more pastries in the near future.

I bought two 4″ Buttertart cake and Carrot cake. They were looking very nice, the guy who served us was helpful and explained that before eating we had to let them at room temp for some time.
The cakes were too sweet. The cream was very grainy, very sweet and buttery. We couldn’t eat too much of it. The sponge was very dry. Overall it was not a pleasant experience and I don’t think I will buy from them in the near future .

We had the buttertart cake and it was one of the best cakes I’ve ever tasted anywhere! A festive cake that’s good for a dinner party, or any time you just want terrific cake!