IL Cortile

I decided to book here based on numerous reviews on NYC pages I follow on Facebook. This was by far the most recommended restaurant in Little Italy. This restaurant is huge on the inside and was decorated so lovely for the holiday season. Our server, Frank, was definitely the kindest server we have had in a long time, if not ever. The menu options are amazing and he was more than happy to help with recommendations. They were so accommodating and on top of everything. The food, especially the sauces were incredible!

I’m a simple man of simple tastes but sometimes you have to go all out. This is probably the best Italian food I’ve had in a long time, and I’ve had all the Italian food all over NJ and NY. The owner was super friendly and super nice, stopping to greet us.

The food is spectacular. Delicious and fulfilling. The atmosphere is so warm and welcoming. (I hear they’re gonna put a speak easy in the back soon). They also have an old school guy take pictures at the table and a guy with an accordion. You don’t get anywhere anywhere!

All and all a wonderful experience and a delight. Don’t sleep on the dessert either.

We’ve dined at this restaurant before, and once again, the food was delicious. The atmosphere is cozy, making it an ideal spot for family gatherings. The service was exceptional; the servers, though I didn’t catch any names, were incredibly friendly, courteous, and helpful. However, I was disappointed when a server accidentally dropped a glass of cocktail, and the owner began yelling at them. So dear owner it’s important to remember that we’re all human and make mistakes. Food and restaurant are everywhere but the only reason why we keep coming to your restaurant is because of the hard work and the service provided by your employees.

We randomly stopped in this restaurant for dinner while we were in NYC for the day. We were drawn to all the Christmas decor and were immediately seated. You feel like you are stepping into a little piece of Italy when you come in. The service was fantastic. Everyone was very friendly and accommodating. Plenty of seating, this place is huge. The meals we got were: Gnocci Pesto, the meat ragu special (only on Sat/Sun), and the Chicken Shrimp Franchise. Everyone thoroughly enjoyed their meals and it was very filling. Absolutely loved the atmosphere!!

Experience the average turned exceptional at Il Cortile Restaurant in Little Italy, NYC. As a seasoned traveler who has explored every continent, I seek more than just a meal – I crave an unforgettable experience. Unfortunately, my recent visit to Il Cortile fell short of my expectations.

While the servers were attentive, the absence of essential components like vinegar, olive oil, fresh cracked pepper, and salt for the bread appetizers left a void in the authenticity of the dining experience. Moreover, the oversight of not offering fresh Parmesan cheese for the main dish further detracted from the overall charm of the meal.

Despite the stunning aesthetics of the restaurant, particularly in the enchanting garden room with its unique glass opening overlooking the cityscape, the lackluster drinks and subpar culinary offerings failed to impress. If you seek an unassuming spot for a decent Italian meal without the need to make a grand impression, Il Cortile may suffice. But for those craving a truly authentic and memorable Italian dining experience, the search for excellence continues.